College Chastity Choice Game 2

We had seen this couple several times in the past at the club, and Katelyn has clearly indicated an interest in playing with the wife.

The main problem was always the husband. It's almost always the husband, to be honest. This is why Heidi, Gabriella, Isabella and even Susan, make for interesting play partners: they aren't with a man!

Well, Gabriella sometimes is, but she doesn't let them participate much, so it suits us. They don't last either. They come once, perhaps twice, and she is single again.

We played with most interesting full swinging couples, and a few of the foursome ones even when interactions were limited.

And that leads to a problem: the pool of new players doesn't grow fast enough for regulars to find new partners and it doesn't take long to realize that most couples in a swingers' club aren't that interesting.

Most people swing because their sex lives are boring, or there are issues in their relationship. Katelyn swings because she is physically unable to be monogamous. She craves, no, she needs variety, even whether good or bad.

A great sexual evening might pump her up and we could have wild sex for a few days, thinking back to that perfect encounter. A horrible session would push her for more and would motivate us to use other sources for extra-conjugal sex.

And yet, the number one advantage of a sex club in general is that if sex sucks with one set of partners, you can pick another!

The two women kiss and touch each other. The reason Katelyn decided to approach them is that we saw the wife having great lesbian sex with some of our partners. Heidi notably speaks highly of her.

Oh, she is already helping Katelyn remove her top. This is interesting.

They saw each other nude often. In fact, last week, we were having sex with a new couple on the same bed they are using while the wife was having sex with Heidi on the next bed. This is probably what changed Katelyn's reluctance to play with them.

I, for one, had been pushing for weeks, but Katelyn knew that the wife didn't want to have sex with other men. You quickly discover these things.

Of course, this is precisely why I wanted Katelyn to play with her, or why I push for more Gabriella since she makes her boyfriend look instead of participating. Because of this, this wife and Gabriella get along fine. She doesn't even mean having sex with her husband, with me, or with other men. It's just her boyfriends who get nothing.

My dream!

Katelyn helps the wife with her top. Neither of the women are wearing a bra, which isn't as frequent as you would think. Katelyn does it to avoid marks on her skin and speed up undressing and dressing back up. See, Katelyn prefers to dress back between scenes, unlike some of the wives. The current partner is the same, but sometimes doesn't, especially after playing in the sundeck.

The wife is sucking on Katelyn's nipples. This is a great sign.

A ton of swingers have a wife claiming to be bisexual but who is in reality bi-curious, and this annoys most of the bisexual girls like Katelyn, Isabella or Heidi.

The main difference is their effort level! Many of these so-called bisexual girls will kiss their partner, but do little more than caress their skin, letting them do all of the work.

For them, lesbian sex is just there to make them wet and prepare them for straight sex. This gets on the nerves of the true bisexual girls who want to make this more of an entrée and instead, a main course. In reality, for many of those girls, it's not even the bread already on the table when you get seated.

The wife is already trying to fully strip Katelyn. I look at my wife and she is smiling. A man going too fast will be a red flag, but when a woman does it, she sees it positively.

Now, I keep saying that Katelyn is bisexual, but the reality is that she isn't. She only is when she comes here. It's weird, isn't it? It's like the price for swinging, in her mind.

This is why we might look like regulars at the club, but the club isn't regular. She prefers to find couples online with which to swing, but she used to just have once night stands, often from Tinder, but she feels guilty having sex on her own and stopped, much to my chagrin.

And yet, she told me she would never be monogamous, and I told her I didn't expect her to be.

Somehow, in her mind, she became convinces it was bad for her to "cheat" on me when we never decided to be monogamous.

Women, am I right?

Speaking of women, Katelyn uses her real name here, but we know that some of the regulars use a fake name, which is fine.

My girlfriend's current partner, however, doesn't want to give her actual name... or a fake name! This makes for weird conversations and it's another factor which made us not play with them yet.

It's weird, isn't it? It's like she thinks that if she doesn't give a name, even a fake one, people will not think of them?

Well, yeah, It's definitely weird. Because the regulars give them nicknames anyway.

Good, she is going down on Katelyn.

Katelyn prefers men. Definitely. Like she told me a few months ago, there is nothing that compares to penises. Nothing can make her cum stronger or better. The muscle mass that is a man, their sweat, our body hair and our natural musk is all intoxicating. In fact, when she does a gang bang, she requires that all men avoid deodorants or scented soap for 24 hours before participating.

But it's not like she doesn't appreciate women. It's like, when in the act, sex is sex, but when talking about it, it's with men, not women.

Still, she doesn't see herself as bi-curious, these women don't give their all, and when it comes to sex, Katelyn is all in.

The husband gets next to me. Of course, he does.

"They are hot, aren't they?"

"That, they are", I reply.

"Hey, sorry if she doesn't want to have other men, you know? I wouldn't mind, but she wants to be only mine when it comes to men"

"I don't mind, but you might not be in the right place for that"

"I know, but we can't find single women elsewhere."

I smile. Indeed, it's not by accident that single women willing to play with couples are nicknamed unicorns.

"It's tough"

"But you really don't mind?", he says

"I really don't"

"Oh, do you think we can see you two again in the future?"

"You'll have to ask Katelyn after we are done. And even then, she might say yes and change her mind later."

"Right. I get that"

"It would help if you gave us names, you know? Even fake ones"

"Dude, your wife decides if you will see us again, mine decides if we give names, you know?"

"We aren't married yet. Almost, but not yet"

The wedding date is in just 2 weeks!

"Oh, sorry. And you are?"

"Evan"

"Nice to meet you Evan", he says as Katelyn already climaxes from the wife!

But as Katelyn recovers, the husband begins to undress.

"Would you mind going down on me while my husband, well, takes you?", asks the Wife

"What?", says Katelyn

I stand to attention. This sounds wild!

"Sorry, if you don't want to, I can understand"

"No, I didn't say no. I just, didn't expect it. Sure, but I usually like to kiss the man first, you know?"

"I bet, but I don't want you two to kiss... just well..."

"Fuck?", says Katelyn

"Yeah"

Katelyn sighs. And I know what it means. She will go through with it, but she doesn't like it. Not one bit.

"Fine", she adds.

"Wicked, thank you, thank you so much", says the wife.

So, Katelyn lifts her butt up, and begins to go down on her partner, while the husband finishes stripping down.

I look, and one of the foursomes in the room is done and getting dressed, while a new throuple, including Heidi, is setting up close by.

You make eye contact with the blonde. She returns a smile, but returns to her one night partners.

Meanwhile, the husband is rock hard, and rolls down a condom. I remember how well gifted he is, which is his main advantage.

He is a little fat, he is already balding a little, he doesn't shave well, and his face shows faint acne scars. But... he is well-equipped where it counts.

Gently, he approaches Katelyn, and grabs her hip with one hand, and his dick with the other, guiding it toward her sweet tight pussy...

This is it! This is what I had been waiting for. Sure, I enjoy when she is with a woman, but I can't compete with them, I don't have the right equipment, you know?

But when a man has sex with Katelyn, this is what turns me on.

Don't think I didn't call her a hotwife, but she rejects the term.

"It's not me who is a hotwife, it's us who are open. You have sex with other people too", she keeps saying.

But it's not what I want. I want her to cuckold me, and this, is possibly as close as I will be.

The husband gets into my wife, and it's almost like Katelyn was being spit-roasted.

It's hot for me, but I don't hear Katelyn moaning or showing clear signs of interest.

This might play either way. She might actually be more interested in finding other men if this is a bust, or she might return to me. It will all depend on how I play it.

The woman doesn't seem too much in it either, only the husband seems to be on top of the world!

And on top of the world he is, going at it like there was no tomorrow, not bothering to check whether Katelyn was liking it or not.

This, of course, creates the result that I feared, he comes without Katelyn getting anything, and thus, she will turn toward me for sex, which is fine, except that I was hoping a man would make her climax, you know?

The husband leaves, and Katelyn stops her oral sex on his wife, who doesn't complain and instead, thanks Katelyn and I.

The wife and the husband do not get dressed. Instead, he grabs the clothes and they leave the room. Katelyn, as always, dresses back, but I can see that she isn't smiling.

She decides to leave, but we do without seeing the husband or the wife.

"This is it. They suck. Swingers suck"

"Sorry to hear that"

"I mean, with a gang bang, each guy is selfish, but together, they create an experience, you know? But just one couple?"

"Anna is throwing her gang bang tomorrow afternoon, at the little dungeon. Do you want to go? She enjoyed your participation the last time"

"How many guys RSVPed?", she asks as we get to the car.

"Let me text her", I replied, but she does while I am driving up. It's 11 guys.

"Ok, could be fun. Do you want to have sex at home, you didn't get anything?"

"Honestly, that turned me off too. Maybe we should focus on a second attempt tomorrow?"

"Anna likes you"

"I know. Could be super fun!"

"Thank honey for taking care of me like that, and sorry again, we could have stayed for you to find someone. Maybe Heidi?"

"N'ah. It's ok. Tomorrow should be a blast.", I say, as she puts her hand on my tigh while I drive.